Central New York is a land of rich folklore, legend and even a few ghost stories. From the mysterious Death Valley Road to a mythical turtle, there are plenty of tales to keep visitors engaged with the odd and occasionally creepy history of Central New York.
Old Phoebe
Canastota, New York
Phoebe Bradley, also known as “Old Phoebe,” was a legendary rambler of the roads of Madison County. She was known for her ceaseless walking and her ability to easily traverse 14 miles in a day. She was also known for her colorful personality, eclectic clothing and her bindle, which she carried all of her worldly possessions in. When Old Phoebe died in 1905, she was believed to be the oldest woman in Madison County and her legend lives on in Canastota.
Nine Mile Swamp
Waterville, New York
Nine Mile Swamp is a place of mystery and intrigue. It is said to be the hideout of the notorious Loomis Gang, who were active in the mid-1800s. The swamp is also said to be the site of several murders and other tragedies. Some people believe that the swamp is haunted by the ghosts of the victims.
Gorton Turtle
West Edmeston, New York
The Gorton Turtle is a giant turtle that is said to have emerged from Gorton Lake to help a local man move a wagon full of rocks. The turtle then disappeared back into the lake, never to be seen again. Some people believe that the Gorton Turtle is a mythical creature, while others believe that it is a real turtle that has simply been rarely seen.
Widow Susan Road
Amsterdam, New York
Widow Susan Road is named after a Scottish woman named Susan Thomas, who became a widow at a young age. Her ghost is said to haunt the road, searching for her husband’s grave. Some people believe that Susan’s ghost is confused because she was buried in the wrong cemetery. Others believe that she is still looking for her husband because she was murdered by him.
Death Valley Road
Johnson City, New York
Death Valley Road is a mysterious road that is shrouded in darkness. There are many stories about tragic deaths that have occurred along the road, including murders, drownings, and hangings. Some people believe that the road is cursed, while others believe that it is simply a dangerous road that has claimed the lives of many people.
Pink Hill Legend
Pitcher, New York
The Pink Hill Legend is a tragic story about a young woman named Zella Droff, who was murdered by her husband. Zella’s ghost is said to haunt the area, looking for a way to escape. Some people believe that Zella’s ghost is trying to find her way back to her home in Pink Hill. Others believe that she is trying to find her husband and avenge her death.
These are just a few of the many folklore sites that are located in Central New York. If you’re looking for a unique and interesting experience involving the history of the unusual variety here, be sure to visit one of these sites and see for yourself if the legends are true.